Fox Sports has spent the last eight years as America's English-language World Cup broadcaster, and if this summer's coverage is any indication, the network will not be missed when its contract expires. The tournament served as a final showcase of Fox's particular talents: hiring British talent to anchor proceedings from a bland Los Angeles studio, assembling studio guests whose contributions ranged from superb to actively harmful, and somehow managing to mispronounce nearly every player name with creative consistency.
The coverage produced moments that captured its essential character. On a sweltering Fourth of July in Philadelphia, with the city's parade canceled due to extreme heat, Fox deployed its American contingent alongside a marching band that had been left with nothing to do. Alexi Lalas waved an enormous flag outside Independence Hall to what appeared to be a crowd of 30 people on the verge of heat exhaustion. It was cable television captured in its purest, most self-aware state of absurdity.
The on-air talent was aggressively uneven. Rebecca Lowe proved herself capable in the main anchor role, corralling an unruly panel with the stern mercy of a respected teacher. Thierry Henry switched between tactical analysis and emotional bombast with the assurance of a complete professional. Clarence Seedorf brought thoughtfulness and genuine warmth to every appearance. But these high points could not compensate for the network's stubbornness in other directions.
Fox Sports CEO Eric Shanks defended Alexi Lalas as the network's cornerstone, the straw that stirs the drink. The metaphor collapsed under scrutiny. Lalas is a cornerstone (solid) and a straw (solid) in contact with a drink (liquid). The logic invited the obvious conclusion that vaporizing Lalas, as many viewers had called for over the years, would at least maintain geometric consistency.
The network's treatment of controversial moments suggested an institution more concerned with protecting its investment than addressing the substance of events. When Iran arrived in the United States under the cloud of an illegal war launched by the American government itself, Fox analysts dismissed the matter as mere noise. FIFA's extraordinary capitulation to Donald Trump to suspend Folarin Balogun's red card ban and allow the US striker to take the field against Belgium was presented as regrettable but ultimately irrelevant. The network functioned as a perfectly pliant vessel for a deeply political tournament.
Fox's casting choices revealed deeper problems. Jameis Winston served as the network's fan correspondent, providing stadium dispatches that left him resembling a man being electrocuted during a baptism. Only Fox would staff such a position with an athlete whose Wikipedia entry included substantial sections on sexual assault allegations, shoplifting incidents, and other controversies. The choice spoke to an organization that saw the role as entertainment first, responsibility never.
The mispronunciations accumulated with stunning regularity. Raúl Jiménez became Jim Ennez. Marc Cucurella transformed into Cuckoo Rella, like the crazy relative no one discusses at family gatherings. Takehiro Tomiyasu emerged as Tommy Yiasou, the wisecracking veteran waiter at a Greek restaurant that has been feeding families since 1978. Rob Stone introduced a feature on joga bonito with the line: We paid a visit to Brazil to learn more about the roots of Joe Go Bonito, making it sound like someone named Joseph had gone absolutely mental on dried tuna flakes at his local okonomiyaki spot. These moments accumulated into an unofficial curriculum in how not to pronounce things.
The decision to house the broadcast team in a bland Los Angeles studio with curved graphic panels designed to resemble the airless rec room of a tech company on the brink of insolvency compounded the sense of smallness. With Manhattan, the Hollywood Hills, and downtown Atlanta's skyway futurism at its disposal, Fox chose a corporate basement instead. Between makeshift stadium desks and glitching green screens, the production felt decarbonated before it began.
The network was not uniformly terrible. It was good only in parts, which may have been the most damaging assessment of all. James Corden's late night show featured beer glasses that remained three-quarters full, headless, and flat throughout the tournament, becoming an unintended metaphor for Fox's approach to covering the world's largest sporting event. Even at America's own World Cup, the network steadfastly refused to deliver the full pour.
With broadcasting rights to 2030 and beyond still up for grabs, Fox's future as the World Cup's American home remains uncertain. The network's eight-year sociological experiment is complete. The study's conclusions are clear.
Author James Rodriguez: "Fox proved that assembling world-class talent and then housing them in a corporate basement while mispronouncing player names is not a sustainable formula for World Cup coverage."
Comments