Democrats are reassessing their hold on Maine's 2nd congressional district after progressive state auditor Matt Dunlap upset the party establishment's handpicked centrist candidate in Friday's primary, leaving national party operatives notably cautious about backing him heading into November.
Dunlap defeated state Sen. Joe Baldacci despite heavy support from the House Democratic Congressional Committee, which had already designated Baldacci to its coveted "Red to Blue" list and bankrolled a $7,500 ad buy for him. The result marks the second straight month a DCCC-backed centrist has fallen to a progressive challenger in a Democratic primary.
Now Dunlap faces Republican former Gov. Paul LePage in a district that Trump carried by nine points in 2024 and that Republicans have targeted since Rep. Jared Golden, an unusually durable Democrat, announced his retirement. LePage swept the district in 2022 while losing statewide by double digits, a stark sign of how Republican-leaning the seat has become.
The tepid response from Democratic leadership suggests they may not aggressively defend the seat. The DCCC and House Majority PAC have avoided committing to treating Dunlap as an official priority, in sharp contrast to their immediate embrace of progressive Randy Villegas after his primary win weeks earlier. HMP had already reserved $8.2 million in general election ad spending before the primary and established a joint fundraiser with Baldacci, but has made no public pivot toward Dunlap.
A Democratic operative told Axios that Dunlap would need to prove his viability and that the party has "plenty of paths to the majority that don't require winning ME-02." One senior House Democrat flatly called the seat "probably lost." Another noted that holding it "was going to be tough anyway without Jared."
The Congressional Leadership Fund, the House GOP's main super PAC, is already stockpiling firepower with $5.2 million in Maine ad reservations. LePage enters the race as a formidable recruit with deep roots in the district and prior electoral success there.
Some Democrats are pushing back against the cautious stance. Rep. Ro Khanna of California warned that starving Dunlap of resources would amount to a "self-fulfilling prophecy" and amount to the establishment prioritizing "boxing progressives out" over winning seats. He argued that the party should back nominees who earned grassroots support, even if not party brass.
The Maine primary troubles compound mounting headaches for Democrats nationwide. The party has also been wrestling with scandals involving Senate nominee Graham Platner, prompting the Democratic National Committee to scrub him from digital ads touting close races in hopes of limiting his drag on the ticket.
Author James Rodriguez: "The establishment's cold shoulder to Dunlap is a calculated bet that they'd rather preserve resources than fight for a Trump-plus-nine district, but it also signals that Democrats may have ceded turf they should be contesting."
Comments