The co-op game Party Animals is facing a wave of review-bombing following the announcement of a $15,000 AI-generated content competition. The developer Recreate Games launched what it calls the Golden Paw Awards, a contest designed to showcase short films, animations, music videos, and other creative works tied to the game.
The catch: entrants must use AI as their primary creative tool. According to the official rules, submissions must feature AI-generated images, video, music, voiceovers, and 3D assets as core elements. The grand prize winner receives $15,000, with runner-up awards ranging from $1,500 to $4,500.
Since the contest was announced, over 800 negative reviews have flooded in on Steam. The game's recent reviews section flipped from "very positive" to "mostly negative" almost overnight. One heavily upvoted review from a player with 26 hours logged stated bluntly: "Rest in peace, loved this game but they're leaning into AI now so I will no longer support this company."
The backlash reflects broader frustration among gamers about the entertainment industry's push toward generative AI. Comments on social media compared the strategy to previous waves of controversial trends. "We saw this exact same song and dance when NFTs were the hot new buzzword," one player observed. Another drew parallels to the normalization of gambling mechanics in sports.
Some pushed back against the criticism. One commenter argued: "I think the general consensus is not the same as a vocal minority. The general consensus still just views AI as a novelty with no strong feelings for or against it." Others pointed out logical inconsistencies in the contest rules, noting that AI-generated content by nature risks plagiarism and unauthorized use of training data.
The AI divide in gaming leadership has become stark. EA CEO Andrew Wilson has called artificial intelligence "the very core of our business," while executives at Square Enix implemented major layoffs to pursue "aggressive" AI integration. Dead Space creator Glen Schofield and former God of War developer Meghan Morgan Juinio have both publicly endorsed AI adoption in development pipelines.
Not everyone is convinced. Take-Two Interactive boss Strauss Zelnick recently dismissed the hype surrounding AI game creation as "laughable." He acknowledged that AI tools might help generate assets but insisted: "That won't help you create hits." His comments came after Google's Project Genie demo, which promised to generate interactive worlds from text prompts, briefly rattled investor confidence in gaming stocks.
Recreate Games has not responded to the mounting player complaints or the sudden shift in the game's Steam rating.
Author Emily Chen: "When a developer bets heavily on the one technology their audience actively despises, they're not innovating, they're just asking for this kind of response."
Comments