The race for California's 22nd congressional district has become a proxy battle for the soul of the Democratic Party itself, pitting a moderate physician against a fiery progressive challenger in a district so poor that locals compare it to Appalachia.
Dr. Jasmeet Bains appeared to be the perfect candidate when she entered the race last summer. A physician working weekends at a community clinic in the Central Valley, she could directly testify to the healthcare devastation wrought by Republican cuts. As the daughter of Sikh refugees and the first Asian American in the California assembly, her personal story matched her political credentials. The Service Employees International Union backed her immediately.
But Bains overlooked a problem: Randy Villegas was already campaigning.
The 31-year-old community college professor and son of Mexican immigrants had spent months crisscrossing the district with a simple message: Bains and politicians like her were part of the problem, not the solution. In a district that is 75 percent Latino with a median voter age of 30, Villegas argued that corporate-backed moderates only blunted their own messaging on healthcare and other issues while alienating the voters most desperate for real change.
Villegas holds a doctorate on Latino voter turnout and sees a groundswell of disillusionment with both parties. He has refused all corporate donations, a stance that carries particular weight in a region where politicians from both sides have sided with agriculture, oil, and pharmaceutical interests on issues like water policy and pesticide regulation that directly harm constituents' health.
"We can't just offer that we're not Trump. We have to stand for something," Villegas said in an interview.
The two Democrats now face each other in a June 2 primary, and the battle reflects a nationwide struggle between moderate and progressive Democratic wings. Bains points to her 2024 re-election to the state assembly, where she outperformed other Democrats by more than seven points, and argues she fits a district where even Democrats tend to be conservative. Villegas has shocked political professionals by outraising Bains and winning endorsements from all four county Democratic chairs, who credit his relentless ground game and enthusiasm as Villegas campaigns in areas outside Bains's home base.
Bains has appeared less visible on the trail, sticking to familiar talking points about healthcare and independence. She declined to debate her rivals and seemed uncomfortable answering critical questions about her voting record. When Joshua Evans, the Tulare County Democratic chair, observed that "you won't receive support unless you show up," he was describing a race that had already slipped from Bains's grasp.
Then the national party intervened.
The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee placed Bains on its "Red to Blue" list of candidates eligible for major funding and support, a decision that local party officials say blindsided them. The DCCC had previously promised not to weigh in ahead of the primary. The reversal sparked fury among county leaders who felt abandoned by Washington insiders reading the district wrong.
"They are frightened. They want to be safe. But in wanting to be safe they hurt the party," said Cathy Jorgensen, the Kings County Democratic chair.
The national intervention poisoned the race. An independent group supporting Bains, the Democratic Majority for Israel, dropped $500,000 on attack ads falsely alleging that Villegas had voted to cover up a school district sex scandal. Local reporting debunked the claim. Villegas had approved a confidential legal settlement but nothing in it silenced victims.
The ad campaign also shifted Bains's position on a key issue. Earlier this year, at a meeting with young district Democrats, she said "yes" when asked if Israel had committed genocide in Gaza. After the pro-Israel money arrived, her position changed: "I approach the word genocide with care, and I don't believe it applies to Israel."
"She's willing to change her answers depending who's in the room," Villegas charged. "The Central Valley deserves better than that."
Bains has countered that Villegas's ads highlighting their shared corporate donors amount to a personal attack. She characterized similar criticism as political violence and an unwarranted assault on a woman of color. "My vote can never be bought," she insisted.
The ugliness has cost Bains support even among her initial backers. Some members of SEIU and the United Domestic Workers union are now walking precincts for Villegas despite their leadership's endorsement of Bains. Ajaib Gill, a prominent SEIU member and public defender, said bluntly: "We messed this endorsement up. Dr. Bains can raise a lot of money, but she doesn't excite anyone."
The race has attracted national attention. Villegas has won endorsements from U.S. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Bernie Sanders, and Dolores Huerta, the farm workers' union icon. Polling shows the race remains close heading into June.
Bains is banking on strength in her assembly district, which covers about two-thirds of the congressional map, and hopes to peel off independents. Villegas is running strong in outlying areas and building momentum among younger, working-class voters hungry for an alternative to establishment Democrats.
Author James Rodriguez: "The DCCC's late intervention backfired spectacularly, turning what should have been a coronation into a civil war that could damage whichever Democrat faces David Valadao in November."
Comments