Federal prosecutors have dropped all remaining charges against four protesters arrested last fall outside an immigration detention center in suburban Chicago, marking another courtroom collapse in the Trump administration's enforcement push against demonstrators.
U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros announced the decision Thursday following a closed hearing about redacted grand jury transcripts. The four defendants, including Democratic congressional candidate Kat Abughazaleh, faced conspiracy charges stemming from a September protest at the Broadview, Illinois facility. They were part of a group that became known as the Broadview Six after a mass indictment.
The protesters were accused of surrounding an Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent's vehicle, scratching "pig" onto the car, and breaking a windshield wiper during a demonstration tied to Operation Midway Blitz, the immigration enforcement blitz launched in multiple cities after Trump took office. Authorities responded with teargas, pepper balls, and rubber pellets.
Questions about how prosecutors handled grand jury records emerged in April, forcing the government to drop charges against two of the six. The remaining four faced reduced misdemeanor charges but those too have now been dismissed with prejudice, barring future refiling.
The case collapse represents a significant setback for the government's legal strategy around protest enforcement. Judge April Perry signaled she may impose sanctions on the U.S. attorney's office over the misconduct, though Boutros did not contest the allegations, calling the conduct "upsetting."
Defense attorneys seized on the dismissal as vindication. Josh Herman, representing Abughazaleh, said the case should never have been filed against anyone exercising First Amendment rights. Co-defendants' legal team noted their clients faced potential prison time "simply for exercising their first amendment rights as decent, honorable citizens."
The Broadview Six prosecution is the latest Trump-era immigration enforcement case to unravel in the Chicago federal courts. Last month, prosecutors dropped charges against Marimar Martinez, an Oak Park schoolteacher charged with impeding federal agents after she was shot five times by a border patrol agent. In January, a jury acquitted Juan Espinoza Martinez, whom the administration had charged with plotting against a border patrol official.
Author James Rodriguez: "When a federal prosecutor is reduced to saying nobody 'intended to mislead' the judge, the case was already dead on arrival, and the public has seen enough to know it."
Comments