Colorado Governor Jared Polis has commuted the sentence of Tina Peters, the former Mesa County clerk convicted of allowing unauthorized access to the county's voting systems, cutting her prison term from eight and a half years to roughly four and a half. Peters is scheduled for release on parole June 1.
Peters was found guilty in 2024 of four felonies and three misdemeanors. In 2021, she permitted Conan Hayes, a former pro surfer affiliated with MyPillow CEO Mike Lindell, to access and copy the county's voting equipment and attend a sensitive software upgrade. Sensitive passwords and data from the Dominion voting machines were later published online by right-wing personalities.
In his clemency letter, Polis argued that the sentence was disproportionate. "This is an extremely unusual and lengthy sentence for a first time offender who committed non-violent crimes," he wrote.
The decision triggered immediate condemnation from Colorado's election officials and the state's clerk association. Jena Griswold, Colorado's secretary of state, said the commutation "validates Trump's basest impulses and emboldens this lawless president." She warned that the move signals to election deniers nationwide that tampering with voting systems carries minimal consequences.
"Clemency also will embolden the election denial movement across the country and will leave a dark, dangerous imprint on American democracy for years to come," Griswold said. She noted she learned of Polis' decision only 45 minutes before it became public.
Matt Crane, executive director of the Colorado Clerks Association, called the decision a sign that "it's open season on our elections and election officials." Election officials across the country have reportedly expressed similar concerns.
When sentencing Peters in 2024, Judge Matthew Barrett was scathing. "You are no hero," he told her. "You're a charlatan who used, and is still using, your prior position in office to peddle a snake oil that's been proven to be junk time and time again."
An appeals court overturned that sentence in April and ordered reconsideration, giving Polis an opening to act. The Democratic governor had signaled his intentions on March 3, when he posted on social media comparing Peters' case to that of former state senator Sonya Jaquez Lewis, who was convicted of submitting forged letters during a legislative inquiry into staff mistreatment. Lewis received probation and community service despite sharing overlapping felony counts with Peters for attempting to influence a public official.
Polis suggested the comparison illustrated broader concerns about sentencing disparities. "Justice in Colorado and America needs to be applied evenly," he wrote, framing it as a question of consistent application of the law.
Election officials and prosecutors immediately pushed back on the analogy. Dan Rubinstein, the district attorney who prosecuted Peters, noted that while the same charge can yield different sentences based on circumstances, commuting Peters' sentence in this instance would constitute "a gross injustice to the affected citizens I represent." Griswold said the cases were fundamentally different. "Peters organized the breach of the election equipment, broke the public trust and attacked the very foundations of our democratic process," she stated. "Her actions are still being used to try to undermine the 2026 election."
Former President Donald Trump, who continues to deny the 2020 election results, has long championed Peters' cause. He issued her a federal pardon last year, though it carried limited effect since Peters faced state charges. He also directed the Justice Department to seek her release and posted on Truth Social describing her as a victim imprisoned for attempting to expose election fraud. Peters, now 73 and in declining health, spent two of her original nine-year sentence in maximum security before the commutation.
Author James Rodriguez: "Polis just handed the election denial movement a victory lap while Colorado's own election officials screamed foul."
Comments