Viktor Orban's defeat in Hungary last month sparked celebrations among democrats worldwide, with many pointing to the election as proof that the populist right is finally losing steam. But experts caution against reading too much into a single electoral upset, warning that the broader movement remains robust and adaptable across the continent.
Orban's loss was not primarily a rejection of his signature policies. The incoming prime minister Peter Magyar actually supports many of his anti-immigration stances. Instead, voters punished the regime for economic deterioration and widespread corruption allegations after 16 years in power. Magyar won by executing disciplined grassroots campaigning in strategically important districts within Hungary's skewed electoral system, a playbook that could work in majoritarian democracies like France or the UK but would struggle in proportional systems like the Netherlands.
The symbolism matters. Orban's fall removes a figurehead and opens doors for EU action previously blocked by his government. But the far right itself is nowhere near collapse. Parties remain in power across the EU, from Italy to Czechia. In Austria and France, they lead polls. Recent setbacks in Bulgaria and the Netherlands represent normal electoral fluctuation rather than ideological defeat.
What makes the far right durable is how thoroughly it has integrated into mainstream politics. Giorgia Meloni's Italy has become a pilgrimage site for politicians burnishing hardline immigration credentials, from European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen to British Labour's Keir Starmer. The centre-right European People's Party openly collaborates with far-right factions in parliament. The EPP has even adopted far-right climate skepticism to retain disgruntled farmers.
Trump's current toxicity offers temporary relief but provides no lasting solution. His extreme behavior paradoxically aids European far-right leaders by making them appear moderate by comparison. When the most powerful nation's president normalizes radical rhetoric, similar arguments become harder to marginalize elsewhere. And when far-right figures like Meloni avoid Trump's erratic style, media and observers mistake strategic restraint for genuine conservatism.
Meloni benefits further from implicit gender bias, with observers assuming women leaders are less extreme than their male counterparts. Her calculated distance from Trump represents tactical repositioning, not ideological rupture. Once his political utility shifts, European far-right movements will recalibrate their relationship with Washington accordingly.
Hungary's election matters as a genuine democratic victory and a tactical lesson in how targeted mobilization can crack entrenched systems. But celebrating Orban's fall while ignoring far-right consolidation elsewhere risks repeating strategic mistakes. Real momentum requires understanding that the movement adapts, fragments, normalizes, and spreads across different national contexts at different speeds.
Author James Rodriguez: "Orban's defeat deserves celebration, but wishful thinking about the death of Europe's far right will only guarantee more painful surprises."
Comments