Chief Justice John Roberts took aim at what he views as a fundamental misunderstanding of how the Supreme Court operates, telling an audience of lawyers and judges in Hershey, Pennsylvania that the American public wrongly sees the justices as ideological players rather than interpreters of law.
Speaking at a conference on Wednesday, Roberts argued that citizens mistake judicial decisions for policy preferences. "I think at a very basic level, people think we're making policy decisions, that we're saying we think this is what things should be as opposed to this is what the law provides," he said. "I think they view us as truly political actors, which I don't think is an accurate understanding of what we do."
The chief justice acknowledged that the court frequently issues rulings that anger the public. He framed this as an unavoidable part of the job. "One of the things we have to do is issue decisions that are unpopular," Roberts said, insisting those opinions flow from constitutional analysis, not partisan calculation.
Roberts conceded that citizens have every right to criticize court decisions, but he expressed concern that public discourse has become too entangled with politics. "We're not simply part of the political process, and there's a reason for that, and I'm not sure people grasp that as much as is appropriate," he said.
The comments come as the 6-3 conservative majority has reshaped major areas of law in recent years. The court has moved rightward on abortion and gun rights, and last week issued a voting rights decision that drew sharp criticism from the left. Roberts did not address specific cases in his remarks.
He also reiterated concerns about the safety of judges, warning that attacks on the judiciary as people rather than on the substance of their rulings cross a dangerous line. "As soon as that happens, that's not appropriate, and it can lead to very serious problems," he said.
Author Sarah Mitchell: "Roberts is right that the public perception gap matters, but his framing ignores how hard it is to separate law from politics when the decisions themselves reshape who wins and loses in American life."
Comments