Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Empire City arrives with an undeniably appealing hook: strap on a headset, grab three friends, and spend hours leaping across rooftops as one of the iconic turtles while cracking jokes and dismantling the Foot Clan. On paper, it's the kind of concept that should feel tailor-made for VR. The execution, regrettably, falls far short of that promise.
The game does land some genuine hits. The writing consistently delivers, with sharp dialogue and punchy banter that captures the turtles' personalities. Playing alongside friends as anthropomorphic reptiles who mirror your real facial expressions creates oddly charming moments, and you'll find yourself drawn into impromptu dance parties at the sewer base just as much as the actual objectives. The parkour mechanics stand out as well, offering zippy movement across the three open-world areas via dashing, grappling, and (eventually) double jumps that make traversal feel genuinely rewarding.
Everything else crumbles under repeated contact. The three hub zones (East Side, Chinatown, and the Docks) are barren and forgettable, populated by an exhausting loop of side quests that offer virtually no meaningful reward. Liberating neighborhoods from Foot Clan control means little when those same areas immediately revert the moment you leave, turning the whole liberation fantasy into busywork. Time trials involving basketball shots and target practice inject brief variety, and scattered collectibles provide some incentive to explore, but these distractions barely cut through the tedium.
Combat represents the biggest disappointment. Attacking reduces to a mindless cycle of slashing and dodging, with inconsistent hit detection that lets attacks pass harmlessly through enemies. Blocking and parrying rarely function as intended. Stealth offers an escape route, but enemy AI is so broken that you can nearly walk past foes undetected, making ninja assassination trivially easy once you realize how little they notice their companions being taken out around them. Neither approach feels satisfying.
The progression system has merit. Collecting trash (literally) to unlock turtle-specific upgrades carries personality: Raphael grows stronger while Donatello gains tech slots. But character progression refuses to transfer between turtles, forcing players to restart development entirely if they want to switch. After an hour as one turtle, experimenting with another means abandoning all advancement.
Technical problems compound everything. In a six-hour campaign, Empire City accumulated shocking numbers of bugs that would halt progress entirely. One instance locked the hacking minigame, another prevented consumable pickups, and several prevented mission objectives from registering as complete. The worst part: restarting a mission after a crash wipes all progress made during that session, turning a 20-minute detour into a full restart or window-tossing frustration.
The multiplayer co-op does ease some pain. Four-player sessions make tedious combat faster and general silliness more memorable. That shared experience genuinely matters when the solo content this thin. Yet even group antics cannot redeem a game this fundamentally broken and repetitive.
Author Emily Chen: "Empire City had every ingredient for a great VR party game and somehow managed to bungle nearly all of them except the writing and the friends you bring along."
Comments