Donald Trump won the presidency by promising working Americans that he would lower prices and create jobs. Six months into his term, his approval rating sits at 37 percent, and the voters who put him there are asking a simple question: what happened?
The answer lies in a stark mismatch between what Trump campaigned on and what he has actually delivered. Last week, Trump posed for a photo opportunity with Sharon Simmons, a 58-year-old delivery driver from Arkansas who has become the public face of his "no tax on tips" initiative. When Trump interrupted the moment to ask her opinion on trans women in sports, Simmons cut through the noise with brutal honesty: "I really don't have an opinion on that. I'm here about 'no tax on tips.'"
That exchange captured the central problem with Trump's presidency. His administration has made culture war battles its defining preoccupation: banning trans athletes from sports, slashing funding for diversity programs, blocking military promotions for women and minorities, pressuring the National Collegiate Athletic Association and Olympic officials to enforce new restrictions. Meanwhile, the issues that actually drove his electoral victory remain unaddressed or have deteriorated.
Gas prices have climbed from $3.10 a gallon to more than $4. Housing costs continue to spiral as immigration enforcement decimates the construction workforce. Employment and wages remain flat. The Supreme Court scuttled his signature tariff proposal, throwing his economic agenda into disarray.
Trump's 2024 victory was never the cultural realignment that media commentators claimed it to be. Exit polling and campaign strategy documents painted a clearer picture: voters were angry about inequality and economic stagnation. They believed Trump could fix their pocketbooks. His campaign ran an effective ad attacking Kamala Harris over support for transition care in prisons, branding him as pro-worker and her as indifferent to ordinary people. But Trump's actual governing agenda has been a festival of grievances aimed at the online manosphere and young men's subcultures, not the working-class households that swung him the election.
The coalition is already fracturing. Latino men, who shifted significantly toward Trump in 2024, have been repelled by his draconian mass detention and deportation program. His broader base of working-class supporters watches ICE officers patrol airports, sees tanks rolling through city streets, and observes their neighbors being dragged away by immigration agents, all while prices keep rising and jobs remain scarce.
Sixty-three percent of Americans now disapprove of Trump's handling of the presidency. He sits atop a lame-duck administration with subordinates openly positioning to replace him. Major policy initiatives are stalled or dead. The Epstein scandal continues to taint his brand and that of his allies.
The irony is thick. Trump built his political career by attacking his Republican predecessors for getting distracted by culture war battles while ignoring the kitchen table issues that working Americans cared about. He promised to be different. Instead, he has fallen into the exact same trap, only with less excuse. He won because voters believed he would change their economic lives, not because they secretly harbored rage against trans athletes or diversity programs.
For Democrats, the moment presents an opportunity they have repeatedly squandered in recent years. But they may not even need to do much. Trump is busy making a historic mistake on his own, launching a regime-change war in the Middle East that his party and the public have no appetite for. The question is whether his imploding coalition can hold together long enough to deliver anything of substance before midterm elections arrive, or whether the working-class voters who carried him to victory will simply walk away.
Author James Rodriguez: "Trump bet his entire comeback on understanding what working people actually wanted, then immediately abandoned that script for the grievances of an online minority. That's not leadership, that's political suicide on an installment plan."
Comments