Rep. Sheila Cherfilus-McCormick walked away from Congress on Tuesday, stepping down just before the House Ethics Committee could vote on whether to recommend her expulsion. The Florida Democrat's sudden resignation spared her party a divisive floor vote that Democrats were bracing to lose.
Cherfilus-McCormick faced 25 ethics violations stemming from allegations that she misappropriated millions in federal disaster relief funds and funneled some of it into her 2022 campaign. The Ethics Committee had already found her guilty last month after a formal hearing. A criminal trial is scheduled for February 2027.
In her resignation statement posted to X, she characterized the Ethics process as a "witch hunt" and said she could not allow her "due process rights to be trampled on." She insisted on her innocence and said stepping down would let her focus on her district and preparing her legal defense.
The timing was no accident. The House requires a two-thirds majority to expel a member, a threshold that would have demanded roughly 70 Democratic votes to remove one of their own. Democratic leadership had been quietly building support for expulsion while facing intense pressure to show they could police their own ranks in an election year and counter Republican accusations of corruption.
Cherfilus-McCormick's departure became the third House resignation in a week tied to ethics or expulsion threats. Republicans Eric Gonzales of Texas and Democrat Eric Swalwell of California both quit ahead of potential removal votes over sexual misconduct allegations.
"The committee has now lost jurisdiction on this matter," Ethics Chairman Michael Guest, a Mississippi Republican, said after she resigned. Guest defended the panel's two and a half years of investigative work, dismissing the notion that it had rushed to judgment on what he called "extremely serious and extremely complicated" allegations.
The Justice Department indicted Cherfilus-McCormick in November on charges of theft and money laundering. Prosecutors alleged her family's health care company received a $5 million overpayment from FEMA during the pandemic vaccination campaign, then routed the funds through multiple accounts and diverted them to her election effort. Court documents also claim she used some of the stolen money to purchase a $109,000 diamond ring. Conviction could bring more than 50 years in prison.
The Ethics investigation began in 2023 at the recommendation of the independent Office of Congressional Ethics. Investigators reviewed more than 33,000 documents and interviewed 28 witnesses before a special adjudicatory subcommittee found her guilty in January of 25 violations. The formal hearing that followed was only the third completed ethics adjudication in recent decades.
Her lawyer had argued the committee should not have proceeded with a public hearing or verdict, contending it would compromise her right to due process in the criminal case. Cherfilus-McCormick herself raised this concern, calling the ethics process a "dangerous path" when a trial loomed.
The Santos precedent hung over the proceedings. In December 2023, the House voted 311-114 to expel Republican George Santos of New York following a damning Ethics report and federal indictment, breaking decades of tradition that expulsion required prior criminal conviction. Only six members have ever been expelled from the House, and three of those were during the Civil War era.
By resigning, Cherfilus-McCormick avoided putting Democrats on record voting for or against her removal weeks before the midterm campaign. Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries and his allies had been attempting to use Republican corruption scandals as a cudgel against the Trump-backed GOP. Her departure meant they would not have to cast difficult votes that could haunt them in competitive races.
Author Sarah Mitchell: "Cherfilus-McCormick's exit shows how the threat of expulsion has become leverage in Washington, not just consequence."
Comments