New York Governor Kathy Hochul is defending her decision to impose the nation's first statewide moratorium on data center development, arguing that major technology companies are moving faster than local governments can manage.
In an interview with NBC News, Hochul explained that applications for new large data centers are accumulating rapidly across small communities throughout the state, overwhelming local officials who lack the resources to negotiate effectively with tech firms. "There are so many applications in primarily small communities across the state of New York," she said. "They aren't quite sure how to manage this."
The governor said localities approached her for assistance after realizing they couldn't match the negotiating power of major corporations. She noted that without state intervention, communities couldn't ensure companies bring their own power or pay premiums to cover grid costs. "They need our help," Hochul said. "They've asked me for help, and at first I thought this is more of a local decision, but then I realized they don't have the negotiating ability, the clout, the wherewithal to be able to negotiate the best benefits."
The pause on state permitting for new large data centers and the direction to regulators to develop new standards represent a significant escalation in the national debate over data center expansion. Both Democratic and Republican lawmakers have sought similar measures, while Senator Bernie Sanders and Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez have called for federal action.
Grassroots opposition to data centers has grown considerably, with groups citing environmental concerns and rising electricity costs. Industry backers counter that such arguments rest on flawed data and overlook the economic benefits development brings to states and communities.
When pressed on whether the pause might hurt New York's ability to compete in the artificial intelligence boom, Hochul rejected the premise as a false choice. She pointed to job creation on Wall Street driven by AI companies seeking talent and innovation. "We don't have that many data centers yet, so we don't need the data centers to support that," she said. "You don't have to have the data centers here to be successful, but that doesn't mean we won't welcome them at the right time and place under really different conditions than exist right now."
Hochul emphasized that her administration is conducting a thoughtful review and stressed her goal is not simply to be first but to "be the first to get it right." The Wall Street Journal's editorial board criticized the move, prompting Hochul to respond with a letter of her own.
The governor noted that momentum for data center pauses is building at the local level across party lines. She cited a recent conversation with a Republican town official on Long Island as evidence. Hochul rejected suggestions that her decision amounts to political pandering, saying those who believe that "don't know me."
Hochul disclosed that her administration held advance conversations with at least one major AI company before announcing the moratorium. She said state officials told the company they would "define the rules of the road, and we'll want you to follow them." She did not identify which company was contacted.
Author Sarah Mitchell: "Hochul's gamble is betting New York can stay competitive without being first in the race to host every data center on the East Coast, and for communities tired of being bulldozed by tech money, that's exactly the breathing room they needed."
Comments