The National Park Service replaced a historically detailed slavery exhibit at the former presidential residence in Philadelphia with panels the Trump administration says offer a fuller picture, sparking fierce backlash from local officials and historians who accuse the government of sanitizing America's past.
The overnight swap occurred on July 15, removing the original installation that had stood for sixteen years. The original panels told the story of nine enslaved people who served George and Martha Washington during the 1790s when Philadelphia briefly housed the nation's capital. Those panels, installed in 2010, became the focus of a six-month legal battle between Philadelphia and the federal government.
The NPS first removed the exhibit on January 22 in response to President Trump's executive order titled "Restoring Truth and Sanity to American History," issued in March 2025. Philadelphia Mayor Cherelle L Parker immediately fought back, filing a lawsuit that initially succeeded: Judge Cynthia M Rufe ordered the original panels reinstated on February 16. The federal government appealed, and in mid-June the U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the Trump administration could proceed with replacement. A three-judge panel formally approved the action on July 3.
"Overnight, under the cover of darkness, the federal government removed panels at the President's House that told a thorough history of Philadelphia," Parker said in a statement, noting that while the court allowed the action, the timing revealed what officials understood about its implications.
The new panels include language acknowledging slavery's evils but shift focus toward enslaved people's relative autonomy within Philadelphia, noting they "experienced a greater modicum of autonomy than elsewhere in the South" and sometimes attended theater with tickets Washington purchased. One panel emphasizes Washington's own unease with enslavement.
The Department of Interior defended the replacement, saying the new panels "acknowledge the evils of slavery, including its injustices and hypocrisies, and, by telling the stories of the nine slaves that Washington kept in the President's House, remind us of their essential humanity."
Philadelphia attorney Michael Coard, who founded Avenging the Ancestors Coalition in 2002 and drove the original memorial's creation, dismissed the notion that enslaved people could experience meaningful autonomy. He drew comparisons to George Orwell's "1984" and warned of broader implications.
"People should really be afraid. This is always the first step to fascism," Coard told reporters. "This is bigger than the government removing some panels at a site in Philadelphia. What if the president doesn't like the Liberty Bell? What if the Statue of Liberty offends the administration's immigration stance? This is a slippery slope."
Coard said Philadelphia still has legal options, including requesting reconsideration from the full Third Circuit Court or appealing to the Supreme Court. "Simply because he came in like a thief in the night and put up new panels doesn't mean that a court can't remove those mythological panels," he said.
The activism against the change has already mobilized. Temple University professor Matt Hall founded Old City Remembers in February to combat what he viewed as historical erasure, and more than 100 volunteers have distributed informational packets containing the original panel text to visitors at the site in recent months.
"Now is not the time to roll over and let them get away with rewriting the history in the way that they think it should be," Hall said. "Our volunteer community is going to continue to come out and give visitors the opportunity to learn what the original text was and to think about why a particular government might want to present history in a certain way or might not want to present that history at all."
Activist Alyssa Bigbee, who began volunteering with Avenging the Ancestors to oppose the changes, said her 10-year-old son inspired her commitment to continuing the fight.
"I'm disgusted that the administration is choosing to hide history, but the truth is, you can't erase it," Bigbee said. "If it takes us on the ground educating people about the truth, then so be it. History will remember that we had cowards in office that chose to erase history and brave people who continue to fight against them."
Author James Rodriguez: "The Trump administration's strategy here is transparent: swap 'difficult' history for a gentler narrative and hope no one notices the difference in a late-night panel replacement."
Comments