Cincinnati's population is growing for the first time in a generation, drawing newcomers seeking refuge from expensive coastal cities. But the influx is exposing a brutal supply problem: the city is losing housing stock faster than it can build new units, shrinking the overall inventory even as demand surges.
Mayor Aftab Pureval calls it a worst-case scenario. "We're such an old city, we're losing housing stock and not building housing fast enough, so we actually have less housing," he said. In 2025, Cincinnati posted the highest percentage increase in average rental costs in the country, competing with New York, Miami, and San Francisco for the unenviable title.
The city has the money to tackle this. In 2024, Cincinnati sold its rail line to Chattanooga to Norfolk Southern for proceeds that created a $1.9 billion trust fund. The deal was controversial and narrowly approved by voters, but it passed with 52% support after Norfolk Southern spent over $4 million on marketing. The fund generates $56 million to $58 million annually in investment revenue, enough to offset about $388 in taxes for every household.
There is one insurmountable catch: state Republicans restricted how the city can spend it. The trust fund can only be used to repair or replace existing infrastructure like streets, sidewalks, and parks. Housing is explicitly off the table.
The restriction reveals the deep political fault line running through Ohio between its blue cities and Republican statehouse. Even though the rail sale won overwhelming legislative support, passing the state senate 30-1, conservative lawmakers embedded guardrails into the deal that prevented Cincinnati's Democratic mayor and city council from using the windfall as they saw fit.
"There was a dim view of whether the current city council would responsibly spend the money, and not just fritter it away on boondoggles," said Bill Seitz, a former Republican lawmaker who helped shepherd the legislation through. "So we limited it to the traditional infrastructure improvement."
Ohio has become a proving ground for state-level Republican restrictions on Democratic cities. Cleveland, Cincinnati, and Clyde all tried to pass gun control ordinances, only to have a Republican state law ban local firearm regulations. Cities have battled the state over minimum wage, plastic bag bans, and vape sales. Each clash reveals a fundamental mistrust.
Republican state senator Louis Blessing, an Ohio iconoclast who initially opposed the rail sale, acknowledged the dynamic bluntly. Republicans view cities "as very blue liberal havens," he said. "And there's a kind of an ethos that they need to be saved from themselves. They'll say that they're overspending. They'll say that they're riddled with crime. So on and so forth. It's antagonistic."
Pureval knew the Republican lawmakers personally. His first political job was as an intern for Mike DeWine, Ohio's current Republican governor, when DeWine served as a U.S. senator in Washington. That experience, Pureval said, showed him that political opponents across the aisle "were, to a large degree, just trying to do what they thought was right, even though I disagreed with how."
The irony is sharp. Cincinnati's fiscal problems did not stem from Democratic mismanagement but from structural decline. The city's population peaked in the 1950s. As white flight and deindustrialization hollowed out the Rust Belt, Cincinnati shed 40% of its residents over five decades, leaving it responsible for expensive infrastructure built for a much larger community with fewer taxpayers to maintain it. Selling the rail line was meant to address a $400 million deferred capital maintenance bill that threatened the city's basic services.
The $1.9 billion fund, roughly $5,000 per resident, represents a generational opportunity that remains largely inaccessible for the city's stated priority. Housing affordability was Pureval's signature campaign issue when he became Cincinnati's first Asian American mayor in 2021. Today, that crisis deepens while billions sit behind political restrictions that reflect state lawmakers' lack of confidence in the city they claim to serve.
Author James Rodriguez: "The real lesson here isn't about rail sales or trust funds. It's that partisan mistrust can render even historic financial wins useless when the people holding the money don't believe the people who need it will spend it wisely."
Comments