Germany's shocking exit via penalty shootout on Monday exposed a troubling gap in preparation. Kai Havertz, Nick Woltemade, and Jonathan Tah all missed from the spot, but the real scandal emerged afterward: four German players had declined to take penalties, leaving backup defender Jonathan Tah, who had never taken one in his career, to attempt the decisive kick. He missed, and the tournament's defending finalists were sent home.
The Netherlands suffered a similar fate against Morocco the same evening, extending a painful history of shootout losses. For Germany, the loss marked their first World Cup elimination via penalties since the procedure was adopted in 1982.
Mauricio Pochettino has no intention of repeating such mistakes. The US head coach revealed this week that his staff has enlisted an outside firm to analyze penalty technique and set pieces, establishing a predetermined order that he declined to fully disclose. His philosophy differs sharply from the reactive approach that doomed Germany.
"We are working because as a coaching staff we believe we can provide some tools to the players to be better and to improve," Pochettino told the Guardian. "It is going to be our decision, the 1, 2, 3, 4, 5. We try to arrive in this moment and not ask the player if he feels confident or not confident."
The admission hints at a deeper strategic framework. Rather than leaving takers to volunteer or rely on in-the-moment bravado, Pochettino's staff will select who shoots when, stripping away the emotional negotiation that plagued Germany. Penalties are now woven into daily training for the USMNT as they prepare for their Round of 32 match against Bosnia and Herzegovina Wednesday evening in the Bay Area. Players gathered as a group to watch Monday's shootouts, treating them as tactical lessons.
The US has never faced a penalty shootout in World Cup history, making this preparation especially crucial. Their only notable shootout memory is Brad Friedel's penalty save against South Korea in 2002.
On the roster, confidence runs high. Christian Pulisic is a clinical finisher, having converted all seven senior team penalties and rarely missing at club level with AC Milan. Forward Ricardo Pepi has not missed since leaving MLS in 2022. Haji Wright has converted 17 of 19 attempts in recent years. Folarin Balogun rounds out a solid core of proven penalty-takers.
Depth becomes hazier. Defender Chris Richards burst into laughter when asked whether he might be called to shoot. "I'm a defender for a reason, man," he said. Still, Richards emphasized that preparation extends across all contingencies. "In training, though, we prepare for everything, whether it's penalty kicks or extra time. We try and not leave any stone unturned."
Monday's shootouts highlighted unorthodox approaches. Players employed stutter steps, short run-ups, and shots across their bodies, with two efforts hitting the post in the Netherlands-Morocco match. When asked whether they might adopt such tactics, US players dismissed the idea. Pulisic shook his head at the notion of changing technique this late in a tournament. "Everyone has their own style. I don't think you watch and can take so much away, or try and change your style in one day."
Richards echoed the sentiment with characteristic humor. "I don't have too much attacking in me, so I'm just picking my spot and going with it."
The broader message from Pochettino's camp is clear: preparation beats improvisation, and psychological readiness matters as much as technical skill. The emotional weight of a shootout cannot be fully replicated in training, but a clear hierarchy and proven technique can steady nerves when they matter most.
Author James Rodriguez: "Pochettino is playing this one smart, but Germany's implosion proves that even advanced planning can only do so much when the moment arrives."
Comments