Jewish Democrats are confronting an uncomfortable reality: their party is moving away from the consensus support for Israel that shaped American politics for decades. At a recent Leadership Summit in Washington, prominent pro-Israel figures within the party attempted to thread a needle, arguing that criticism of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government need not mean abandoning support for the nation itself. But whether rank-and-file Democrats are listening remains an open question.
The numbers tell a stark story. NBC News polling found that 57% of Democrats now hold a negative view of Israel, up sharply from 35% in 2023. Two-thirds of Democrats say their sympathies lie with Palestinians rather than Israelis, compared to just 18% in 2013. For the first time in two decades of measurement, Gallup found Americans overall more sympathetic to Palestinians than Israelis, a shift driven entirely by movement among Democrats and independents.
Hamas' 2023 attack on Israel, which killed about 1,200 people and resulted in 251 being captured, initially reinforced bipartisan support for the country. Israel's military campaign in Gaza has obliterated that consensus. The shift has already begun reshaping Democratic politics. More than a dozen Democratic lawmakers have described Israeli conduct in Gaza as genocide. Pro-Israel groups like AIPAC have made headlines by spending heavily in primaries against progressive candidates. Upcoming races, including a rematch between Rep. Wesley Bell and former Rep. Cori Bush, and a Michigan Senate contest, promise to intensify the clash.
At the summit, former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi quoted an Israeli poem, arguing that differences with Israeli leaders should not weaken American support for Israel itself. "Could be about the United States," Pelosi said. The argument was direct: one can love a country while opposing those currently governing it.
Congressional Democratic leaders appear to agree. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer and House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries both spoke at the summit, reaffirming their support for Israel and commitment to fighting antisemitism. Halie Soifer, CEO of the Jewish Democratic Council of America, told reporters that party leadership "continues to strongly stand with our views and values."
Yet that leadership unity masks growing fissures in the membership. An increasing number of Democratic senators have voted to block certain weapons sales to Israel. The most recent round of votes to disapprove of specific bomb and bulldozer sales drew a clear majority of Democratic senators. Soifer acknowledged the shift, framing it as a message about opposing Netanyahu's policies rather than abandoning Israel's security needs. "It doesn't mean they've turned their back on the security relationship with Israel writ large," she said.
Democratic Sen. Chris Coons of Delaware warned his colleagues about the risks. "I think we are at risk of some of my colleagues, in trying to send a message to Netanyahu or in opposition to his policies and stances, to be misunderstood as abandoning that commitment," he said.
The Association's Strategy
Soifer's group is preparing a seven-figure campaign to mobilize Jewish voters. That includes plans to oppose Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan's Senate race, a former public health official who recently appeared with left-wing streamer Hasan Piker and declined to disavow his inflammatory past comments about Israel and Hamas. When Piker said on a podcast that he would "vote for Hamas over Israel every single time," it crystallized concerns among pro-Israel Democrats about their party's left flank.
Piker wields significant influence, particularly among younger voters. Some progressive candidates have kept their distance from his most controversial statements, while others have embraced platforms alongside him. The associations have not gone unnoticed. When Soifer was asked about Graham Platner, the leading Democrat in Maine's Senate race who has faced criticism for a tattoo that resembled Nazi symbolism, she suggested her group might stay out of that race entirely, saying "it could be that at the end of the day, we just stay out of Maine, don't get involved, even if the party has decided to fully embrace Platner."
Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey, speaking at the summit, offered a frame that many Jewish Democrats recognize. "You can be a patriot and be a lover of your country and simultaneously believe that those governing it are wrongheaded. That is how I feel about America. That is simultaneously, in many senses, how I feel about Israel," he said. But he also warned that "free speech dovetails into antisemitism and hate." The real test, Frey suggested, is having the political courage to challenge your own side.
What's emerging is not a simple binary between pro-Israel and pro-Palestinian camps, but a more complex struggle over what Democratic support for Israel should look like in an era of deep disagreement about Netanyahu's government and the war in Gaza. Pro-Israel Democrats insist the distinction is clear. Whether their party learns to make it remains uncertain.
Author Sarah Mitchell: "The Democratic Party's fracture on Israel is real and growing, but the real test will be whether the party can articulate a vision that distinguishes between supporting a nation's right to exist and approving every policy its government pursues."
Comments