Donald Trump departed Beijing on Friday with pageantry, champagne toasts, and a Chinese military band playing YMCA, but left behind the thorniest geopolitical problems that brought him there in the first place. The two-day summit with President Xi Jinping produced no swift resolution to the Iran war, no definitive stance on Taiwan's fate, and only vague commercial promises that officials on both sides have yet to confirm in detail.
The spectacle was undeniable. Beneath giant chandeliers and elaborate backdrop design, Trump sat at Thursday's state banquet alongside a cast that would have seemed impossible a decade ago: tech billionaire Elon Musk, Fox News host turned Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, and a roster of Silicon Valley executives. Guests ate crispy beef ribs, Beijing roast duck, and lobster in tomato soup as the mood turned convivial after the summit's opening day.
Yet the substance lagged far behind the ceremony. Rush Doshi, director of the China Strategy Initiative at the Council on Foreign Relations, told reporters the summit was "heavier on symbolism than substance" with "a focus on managing problems, not solving the problems that exist between the US and China."
Xi personally escorted Trump through manicured gardens at Zhongnanhai, the secretive Communist Party leadership compound, where the president marveled at roses he called "the most beautiful anyone has ever seen." Trump praised Xi as "all business" yet also "a warm person," while Xi called the visit historic and spoke of a "constructive, strategic and stable" relationship. But beneath the flattery lay profound disagreements that neither flowery rhetoric nor careful stagecraft could mask.
Taiwan hung over the talks like an unresolved crisis. Xi warned Trump in unusually stark terms that mishandling the democratic island claimed by Beijing could push the two nations toward "clashes and even conflicts." Trump later told reporters that Xi asked directly whether the US would defend Taiwan if China attacked, but he refused to answer: "There's only one person that knows that, and it is me."
That evasion alarmed officials in Taipei watching Trump's rhetoric with mounting nervousness. The president has repeatedly complained that Taiwan "stole" America's semiconductor industry and demanded the island pay more for its defense. Before the summit, Trump hinted he might reconsider an $11 billion weapons package for Taiwan approved by his administration last year. Speaking aboard Air Force One Friday, he said only that he would decide "over the next fairly short period of time."
On Iran, Trump emerged insisting that China and the US were aligned, claiming Xi had agreed that Tehran must reopen the Strait of Hormuz and promised China would not supply Iran with military equipment. Yet Beijing's public statements were more restrained, with China's foreign ministry saying the conflict "should never have happened" and calling for shipping routes to reopen without endorsing Trump's broader approach.
The strait, through which roughly one-fifth of the world's oil previously flowed, has been effectively closed since the war began 11 weeks ago following US and Israeli strikes on Iran. Oil prices have surged toward $109 a barrel, raising recession fears and dragging Trump's approval ratings to historic lows.
Trump returned with promises of sweeping commercial gains. He claimed China would buy "billions of dollars" worth of American agricultural goods, particularly soybeans, offering potential relief to US farmers crushed by years of trade tension and Chinese shifts toward Brazilian suppliers. He also announced what could become one of history's biggest aircraft deals, saying China agreed to purchase 200 Boeing jets immediately with possible expansion to 750 planes.
But Chinese officials did not confirm the Boeing order, leaving the specifics murky. Trump's trade representative said Washington expected "double-digit billions" in agricultural purchases over three years, yet concrete timelines and enforcement mechanisms remain undefined.
Trump also announced a new proposal for a trilateral nuclear arms control agreement among the US, Russia, and China, claiming he received "a very positive response." But hope for new guardrails on the AI arms race between the two superpowers appeared dashed, despite the presence of Elon Musk, Tim Cook, and Jensen Huang at the summit.
On human rights, Trump said he raised the cases of imprisoned Hong Kong media tycoon Jimmy Lai and detained Chinese pastor Jin Mingri. Trump suggested Xi was giving "very serious consideration" to the pastor's case but called Lai's situation "a tough one."
For a president who normally dominates daily press cycles, Trump was unusually subdued in Beijing. His notoriously hyperactive social media presence went largely dormant during the two-day visit, an apparent act of deference to Xi. When asked by reporters if he considered Xi a dictator, Trump demurred: "I don't think about it. He's the ruler, he's the president of China. I don't think about it." He continued: "You have to deal with what you have. I respect him. He's very smart."
The farewell was as meticulously staged as the welcome. Schoolchildren in light blue and white waved flags in coordinated precision, chanting "Warm farewell!" as Trump climbed the stairs to Air Force One. But his final social media post revealed his true preoccupation: a photograph of himself and Xi outside the Great Hall of the People with the caption, "China has a Ballroom, and so should the U.S.A.!" He was already focused on his pet project, a new $400 million ballroom at the White House.
Democratic senators including Jeanne Shaheen, ranking member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, condemned Trump for squandering an opportunity. "President Trump failed to use his summit with Chinese President Xi Jinping to advance any objectives important to the American people," they said in a joint statement, citing his inability to counter China's "unfair trade practices and military aggression, preserve American technological and economic leadership, stand up for human rights or strengthen deterrence to prevent a conflict over Taiwan."
Author James Rodriguez: "For all the ceremonial grandeur, Trump's Beijing trip was a masterclass in trading long-term strategic leverage for short-term optics and vague commercial promises that may never materialize."
Comments