Virginia's Supreme Court blocked new congressional maps that voters had just approved, dealing Democrats a major blow weeks before the midterm elections. The court ruled Friday that the state legislature violated constitutional procedures when it advanced the redistricting amendment, which would have flipped as many as four seats from Republican to Democratic control.
The maps had cleared a voter referendum last month with 52 percent support. But the court found the legislature had approved the underlying constitutional amendment in October 2025, before early voting had even concluded in the general election that November. State constitution requires amendments be approved twice: once in the regular legislative session, then again in the session following an election cycle. By passing it before Election Day ballots opened, Democrats violated that sequence.
"This constitutional violation incurably taints the resulting referendum vote and nullifies its legal efficacy," the justices wrote.
Republicans celebrated immediately. Richard Hudson, chair of the National Republican Congressional Committee, called it a victory that "restores fairness and protects the future of the Commonwealth" after Democrats' "corrupt scheme to rig the map." Joe Gruters, Republican National Committee chair, added a blunter message: "Democrats just learned that when you try to rig elections, you lose."
Democrats fired back. Suzan DelBene, who heads the House Democrats campaign arm, said "four unelected judges decided to cast aside the will of the voters." House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries called the decision "unprecedented and undemocratic," saying Democrats are exploring options to overturn it.
The Virginia ruling arrives as Republicans across the South aggressively redraw their own districts following a weakened Voting Rights Act. Florida Governor Ron DeSantis signed a new map last week expected to oust four Democratic incumbents. Meanwhile, gerrymanders in Texas, North Carolina, and Missouri could eliminate as many as seven Democratic seats nationwide. Democrats have one bright spot: California voters approved a map that could flip five Republican seats.
The original amendment, approved by voters in 2020, was meant to ensure Virginia's congressional maps reflected the state's Democratic lean. Instead, the court's decision keeps Republican control of four of Virginia's five House seats intact heading into November.
Author James Rodriguez: "Courts shouldn't be deciding elections, but when legislatures botch the procedural rules this badly, they hand judges exactly the opening they need."
Comments