Crimson Desert's main character Kliff has become something of a running joke among players. The gruff warrior responds to nearly every dramatic plot point with a flat "Alright," a catchphrase that spawned countless memes. But the disconnect between Kliff and the game's narrative problems runs deeper than a single repeated line.
The criticism extends beyond Kliff himself. Reviewers and players have consistently flagged the game's story as its weakest component, despite widespread praise for the open world, combat systems, and overall gameplay. The narrative is described as aimless, the characters as forgettable, and entire plot threads as cringe-worthy or pointless. One notable example involves a character death that occurs offscreen before the story even begins, yet the game spends multiple funeral scenes over many hours trying to make players care.
Pearl Abyss CEO Heo Jin-young acknowledged the criticism shortly after launch. "I sympathize to some extent with the disappointment users feel regarding the story," he said. "I think it would have been nice if we could have done a better job with it. The production team tried to make up for the shortcomings in the remaining time, but ultimately, we focused on strengthening the gameplay, which is what we do best."
Voice actor Alec Newman, who performs Kliff, explained that the character and story underwent significant changes during development. He described the challenge of portraying someone so emotionally reserved across 150 hours of gameplay. "It's very very hard to play 150 hours with somebody who doesn't give anything away ever," Newman said in recent comments. He noted that the team decided partway through development that they wanted Kliff's family connections to resonate, leading to a push to show more emotional depth where possible.
Now Trevor McEwan, the motion capture actor and physical model for Kliff, has offered his own perspective on the character's apparent detachment. In a Reddit AMA, McEwan suggested that Kliff's emotional suppression was deliberate rather than an oversight.
"Everything was done intentionally for the most part from my interpretation of Kliff and his character," McEwan explained. "He has a lot going on under the surface but is very guarded of that. The family he made with the Graymanes and their mission is the most important thing to him. So he attached himself a lot to that."
When pressed about the game's paper-thin narrative, McEwan defended Crimson Desert's overall design philosophy. "Yeah, I get that, but I think what it lacks in narrative it more than makes up for in other aspects," he said. He also pointed to hidden lore scattered throughout the world as a counterpoint to players who criticize the main story's weakness.
The tension between what Crimson Desert was designed to be and what players wanted remains unresolved. Some treat it as a sandbox adventure where story takes a backseat to exploration and combat. Most, however, agree that the plot, characters, and dialogue fall short of what a game with this many cutscenes and character conversations should deliver. Yet the game remains a commercial juggernaut, having sold over 5 million copies in less than a month, suggesting that plenty of players have made peace with prioritizing gameplay over narrative.
Author Emily Chen: "McEwan's defense of intentional emotional guardedness might satisfy some, but it doesn't solve the fundamental problem: a stoic character needs a story compelling enough to justify 150 hours of watching him barely react to it."
Comments