A determined coalition of conservative activists is escalating pressure on President Trump to deliver the sweeping deportation agenda that defined his campaign, warning that backsliding on immigration enforcement would amount to a betrayal of his core supporters.
The Mass Deportation Coalition, a network spanning GOP think tanks, advocacy groups, and grassroots Republican organizations, contends that the White House is softening its rhetoric ahead of midterm elections and caving to business interests seeking cheaper labor. The group is now pushing what it calls "Phase 2" of enforcement: at least one million deportations annually.
"The President has only gotten pressure in his face to tone down the enforcement," said Mike Howell, a former Homeland Security official in Trump's first term who leads the Oversight Project. "The truth is the first year was not a year of mass deportation. A conscious decision was made to go after the worst first, which was a deviation from the central campaign promise."
The coalition's frustration centers on what it views as political compromise. Mark Morgan, former head of ICE and Customs and Border Protection, framed the group's role as providing Trump with a "right flank," pushing back against advisors Morgan believes are steering the president away from his promises.
"If Trump had said what industry wanted on the campaign trail, 'I'm going to keep the illegals here so you can have cheap labor,' he would not be in the White House," Howell said. "He'd be in a prison cell right now."
The coalition's membership reflects the breadth of the immigration-hardline movement. It includes the Heritage Foundation, newer advocacy outfits like the Immigrant Accountability Project, and clusters of Young Republican clubs. Members believe they still hold public sentiment on their side, despite incidents that drew criticism.
Internally, coalition leaders see the administration as divided. Stephen Miller, the deputy White House chief of staff, is viewed as a natural ally, though the group says it has not met with him directly. Some congressional Republicans, including Rep. Chip Roy of Texas and Sen. Mike Lee of Utah, remain committed to the hardline position. Portions of the Department of Homeland Security staff have attended informal coalition meetings.
The primary opposition, according to Howell, comes from advisors with ties to business lobbies and former lobbyists now within the administration, though he declined to name specific staffers.
The White House rejected the characterization of division. "Nobody is changing the Administration's immigration enforcement agenda and the President's entire team is on the same page when it comes to implementing his policies," said Abigail Jackson, a White House spokeswoman.
The numbers reveal a more modest pace than the coalition demands. Immigration and Customs Enforcement logged roughly 350,000 removals in fiscal year 2025, up from 271,400 the prior year under President Biden. Morgan described this as a relatively modest increase given the resources expended. The administration has touted more than two million self-deportations but has not provided a comprehensive year-end report from ICE to Congress detailing first-year deportation totals from Trump's return to office.
Border Patrol has similarly withheld official figures on apprehensions and on what agents call "got aways," people who cross undetected. Morgan said he has heard that figure hovered between 25,000 and 30,000 last year. The Department of Homeland Security's statistics office has not updated its public database since the Biden administration left office, a change from its prior practice of posting monthly deportation data.
This week, the coalition released a policy playbook for the executive branch outlining more than a dozen enforcement proposals. The group has been building relationships across Capitol Hill, DHS, and relevant agencies over more than a decade, Morgan said, with the goal of keeping the administration from abandoning its course.
The contrast Howell draws is stark. At the Republican National Convention, immigration united the party. Delegates on the convention floor waved "mass deportation now" signs. But Howell sees a fundamental split between the grassroots and the establishment.
"I'll put it to you this way: The people holding the signs on the floor in the general seating, those are my people," Howell said. "The people in the suites, those are not my people. That's who we're going up against."
Author James Rodriguez: "If the White House is truly unified on mass deportation, it shouldn't need this much convincing from the right."
Comments